New tax return rules for company directors create uncertainty

CREATED BY ROGER EDDOWES Published: 11/06/2026 @ 09:00AM #TaxReturnRules #CompanyDirector #HMRCGuidance #SelfAssessment #Reporting #Traders

The new tax return rules for company directors aim to improve reporting but also cause confusion. Directors and traders must provide more detail in their self-assessment returns, yet HMRC guidance leaves gaps. Many will wait for clearer answers ...

Uncertainty looms as new tax return rules for company directors spark confusion and concern

The new tax return rules for company directors are designed to tighten reporting, but I believe they also introduce a fair amount of uncertainty for anyone trying to get self-assessment right the first time. For many company directors, the change feels less like a simple update and more like a test of how well HMRC guidance aligns with real life.

Directors are being asked to provide more detail about
their role, the company's status, and in some cases, their
dividend income and shareholding!

While this may seem simple on paper, it can become complicated when the facts are not clear. A director who is unpaid, holds multiple appointments, or has fluctuating shareholdings might find filling out the form more challenging than anticipated.

The key question is not whether the information matters, but where it should be entered and how HMRC wants it presented.

The new tax return rules for company directors appear to assume a neat structure, whereas I know that many businesses operate in a far less neat way. For example, an unpaid director may reasonably wonder whether the employment pages must still be completed or whether the details can be entered elsewhere in the return.

The same uncertainty applies to multiple directorships. Some of my clients act as trustees or hold multiple board roles, and software does not always handle this gracefully. If the return software limits the number of entries, the taxpayer is left guessing whether HMRC will accept an alternative disclosure. This is not ideal for director responsibilities, especially when penalties can follow incomplete reporting.

There is also a practical problem for directors of
close companies that are not shareholders!

The new boxes seem to assume that share ownership always exists, but that is not always the case. When a nil holding does not fit neatly into the filing software, the taxpayer is left with an awkward question: how should the return be completed without triggering an error?

HMRC guidance will be crucial here, particularly on when a trade starts or ends, how percentage ownership should be measured, and how to handle ownership split across share classes.

Until that guidance is clearer, I can see the new tax return rules for company directors creating more administrative burden and significant uncertainty. Businesses are not seeking leniency so much as a workable process that reflects how company directors actually operate.

The new tax return rules for company directors may improve data quality over time, yet for now, they leave many taxpayers navigating self-assessment with more questions than answers.

I think the intent behind the changes is understandable, but the delivery still feels underdeveloped.

Until next time ...

ROGER EDDOWES
Join our mailing list! Click here and be one of the first to know when we publish a new blog post!

Share the blog love ...

Buffer Facebook Twitter Linkedin Pinterest WhatsApp #TaxReturnRules #CompanyDirector #HMRCGuidance #SelfAssessment #Reporting #Traders

About Roger Eddowes ...
Roger trained at Edward Thomas Peirson & Sons in Market Harborough before working at Hartwell & Co, followed by Chancery, as a partner. He started Essendon Accounts and Tax with Helen Beaumont in 2014 as a general practitioner with a hands-on approach. Roger loves getting his hands dirty, working with emerging, small-to-medium and family businesses to ensure they receive the best possible accountancy advice. Roger utilises an extensive network of business contacts to leverage the best guidance and practical solutions.

More blog posts for you to enjoy ...
		Self employed taxpayers warned about class 2 NIC record errors HMRC has spotted errors in Class 2 NIC records affecting some self-employed people who did not register properly. The good news is that fixes are being rolled out, and some taxpayers may be able to top up gaps later. It is wo...
		Andy Burnham's tax plans: what could they mean for businesses and taxpayers? With Andy Burnham declaring himself 'ready' to lead the country, attention has naturally turned to what a Burnham government might mean for the UK's tax system ......
		How the recent heatwaves have cost businesses billions The record-breaking June heatwave was more than just a talking point. According to new research from the London School of Economics (LSE), the exceptionally high temperatures led to an estimated 24 million lost working hours,...
		HMRC's mandatory direct debit for VAT and PAYE plans explained Mandatory direct debit for VAT and PAYE could soon become the norm for most businesses. The plan aims to improve collections and reduce errors, but it may create headaches for some businesses, especially those using other pay...
		Are you thinking of employing young workers this summer? The summer holidays are a popular time for young people to gain their first work experience, and many businesses welcome the extra help during their busiest months ......
		Why Artificial Intelligence is changing recruitment Artificial intelligence is no longer something businesses are simply experimenting with, and it is rapidly becoming part of everyday life, especially in recruitment. The latest AI hiring trends suggest that this shift will on...
		Growing our team to support yours At Essendon, we believe that good accounting is about more than numbers. It's about giving business owners confidence that everything is organised, properly handled, and under control ......
		Millions of taxpayers could soon have to pay their tax earlier Millions of taxpayers could pay their tax earlier under HMRC's proposed self-assessment changes. The move may smooth tax deadlines, but it could also tighten cash flow. For many, the real issue will be how quickly the system ...

Other bloggers you may like ...
		Why adult children worry about parents who live alone Posted by Steffi Lewis on https://www.yourping.uk When parents reach a stage where they're happily living on their own, it can be a source of pride for the whole family. They're independent, capable, ...
		Understanding property refurbishment costs before you buy Posted by Sarah Hannaford on https://blog.sarahpasolutions.co.uk One of the biggest mistakes new property investors make is underestimating the costs of property refurbishment. It's easy to spot a bargain property a ...
		Could your everyday shopping pay your household bills? Posted by Davina Farrer on https://blog.joindavina.co.uk What if the money you already spend every week could start helping to pay your household bills? It sounds a little too good to be true, but sometimes ...
		Fraud, Fraud, Fraud! What's The Cost To Your Business? Posted by Pritesh Ganatra on https://blog.btsuk.net Did you know that small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) account for 99.9% of the businesses in the UK? At the start of 2023, there were estimated ...