How HMRC's Tax Battles on Snacks Are Shaping UK Food Industry

CREATED BY ROGER EDDOWES Published: 22/05/2025 @ 09:00AM #VATConfusion #SnackTaxBattle #UKFoodRegulations #LegalDisputes #FoodBusinessImpact #ConsumerConfusion

From Jaffa Cakes to Pringles, the ongoing tax battles on snacks in the UK highlight the confusion over VAT regulations. With various rulings leading to strange classifications, I'll explore how these legal disputes impact food businesses and consumers alike ...

Tax battles on snacks, Crispy chips and sugary treats, Wallets grow thinner

The world of Value Added Tax (VAT) is often bewildering, and HMRC finds itself embroiled in a series of amusing yet critical legal tax battles on snacks. Legislation that dictates which food items are subject to zero VAT rates and which are standard rated has resulted in a labyrinth of confusion for manufactures, retailers, and, ultimately, consumers.

The absurdity of these proceedings has turned everyday
snacks into courtroom drama!

To understand the implications, it’s crucial to first grasp what VAT involves. Introduced through the Finance Act of 1972, VAT now constitutes a significant portion of the treasury's revenue, accounting for roughly 20% in 2022.

However, the rules that govern VAT, particularly in relation to food items, are anything but straightforward. Generally, food intended for human consumption carries a zero-rating; yet, exceptions exist where confectionery, hot foods, and savoury snacks fall under the standard rate VAT. It is here that the tax battles begin, as manufacturers look to navigate an often arbitrary regulatory framework.

For example, one of the most famous legal disputes was triggered by the iconic Jaffa Cake. In 1991, a Tax Tribunal ruled that these delectably soft treats are cakes, and thus should enjoy the benefits of zero-rating thanks to their sponge-like texture. Yet, not all snacks have been so fortunate.

In 2009, the potato-based phenomenon known as Pringles faced the taxman, ultimately being classified as a potato crisp, thus holding a VAT liability due to its composition. This case stands as a prime example of how seemingly trivial attributes of food items can engender significant tax ramifications.

And the legal wrangling doesn't end here!

Consumers may be surprised to learn that, despite the familiarity of beloved snacks like Monster Munch or Wotsits, these snacks are subject to VAT while other items, such as Skips, remain exempt. The seemingly nonsensical classifications evoke a sense of frustration among businesses trying to comply with the law, not to mention the complications it introduces in tax compliance and pricing.

A recent bizarre twist in these legal tax battles on snacks involved giant marshmallows, taking a new turn as the court debated whether these marshmallows deserved VAT liability based on how they are consumed. This surreal examination of how people eat snacks certainly puts the absurdity of tax laws on display.

I sometimes shake my head in disbelief at the controversy that embodies the ludicrous nature of the VAT legal framework, leading many to question the wisdom behind HMRC’s relentless pursuit in these cases.

The ongoing tax battles on snacks illustrate a need for reform. Regulatory overhauls are essential to clarify the application of VAT to food products and provide consistency across the market. I feel that the government really needs to reevaluate these guidelines, introducing a new era of clarity for the food and snack industry.

VAT classifications need to become more
logical and straightforward!

While these tax battles may be rooted in law and finance, they also underline an important cultural aspect—the beloved snacks that fill pantry shelves across the nation are now embroiled in an ongoing saga of legal contention.

It’s a peculiar crossroads of tax policy and culinary enjoyment, and always promises amusement and perplexity in equal measure.

Until next time ...

ROGER EDDOWES
Join our mailing list! Click here and be one of the first to know when we publish a new blog post!

Share the blog love ...

Buffer Facebook Twitter Linkedin Pinterest WhatsApp #VATConfusion #SnackTaxBattle #UKFoodRegulations #LegalDisputes #FoodBusinessImpact #ConsumerConfusion

About Roger Eddowes ...
Roger trained at Edward Thomas Peirson & Sons in Market Harborough before working at Hartwell & Co, followed by Chancery, as a partner. He started Essendon Accounts and Tax with Helen Beaumont in 2014 as a general practitioner with a hands-on approach. Roger loves getting his hands dirty, working with emerging, small-to-medium and family businesses to ensure they receive the best possible accountancy advice. Roger utilises an extensive network of business contacts to leverage the best guidance and practical solutions.

More blog posts for you to enjoy ...
		HICBC: New process for paying the High Income Child Benefit Charge The High Income Child Benefit Charge can now be paid via PAYE. No more self assessment just for HICBC, if eligible. Here's how the rules, thresholds and practical steps work ......
		Understanding Tax On Pensions Without The Jargon Here's a clear guide to tax on pensions, from allowances to lump sums and tax codes. It also covers savings, dividends, and side income. No fuss, just the essentials ......
		Can HMRC Take Money From Your Bank Account Without Permission? Wondering if HMRC can take money from your bank account without permission? Yes - sometimes, under strict rules and safeguards. Here's how it works, what to expect, and how to protect your finances ......
		Tax Resistance Threatens Reeves' Strategy As Patience Wears Thin Tax resistance is building as households and firms hit their limits. Reeves' strategy risks faltering without a credible quid pro quo. A reset on spending and growth may be unavoidable ......
		Simple Assessment Payment Plans: Apply Online To Spread Your HMRC Tax Bill Here's how simple assessment payment plans work and who qualifies. Taxpayers can apply online to spread tax bills, with interest still charged. It's quick, practical, and often penalty-friendly ......
		CPI inflation rise to 3.8%: what it means for the UK Here are my thoughts on the CPI inflation rise to 3.8% and why it matters to both business and consumers. Prices are heating up before likely cooling off in a few months. Small firms should prep for volatility and policy shif...
		Speculation Over the Autumn Budget 2025: What Might Be Announced? Here's a quick take on the Autumn Budget 2025. Expect debate over borrowing, tax changes, and what HMRC may tweak, with winners and losers likely. Keep plans flexible while the chancellor weighs government spending needs ......
		Evidence Needed For Every Pension Tax Relief Claim From September 2025 As of 1st of September 2025, every Pension Tax Relief claim now needs evidence and can't be made by phone. Claims must be made online or by post, with self-assessment via the return. Here's what to provide and who can claim, ...

Other bloggers you may like ...
		From Inbox to Impact: Turn Emails into Trust-Building Blog Posts Posted by Steffi Lewis on https://www.sblogit.com You can go from inbox to impact by quickly and easily turning repetitive emails into weekly blog posts with sBlogIt! done-for-you blogging service. We ...
		The Importance Of Being Earnest Posted by Pritesh Ganatra on https://blog.btsuk.net I still believe in the notion that 'people buy from people', however, we seem to be in a world where people are being pressured into buying technology ...
		The DIY business health check: See What's Really Going On Posted by Steph Birch on https://blog.birchstrategicservices.com Here's a DIY business health check to surface real bottlenecks fast. Skip the theatre and find the friction. Every growing firm needs a clear view of ...
		Download an Anti-Money Laundering package that actually helps! Posted by Alison Mead on https://blog.siliconbullet.com Want Anti-Money Laundering made simple? My updated AML package offers templates, checklists, and practical tips that slot straight into your workflow. ...